Asked by Meyber Mendieta on Jun 26, 2024
Verified
Which of the following arguments commits the accident fallacy?
A) Tabitha had a collision with a bus.Therefore, Tabitha is to blame.
B) It is wrong to take from others against their will.Therefore it is wrong for the government to tax the people.
C) Skyscrapers require careful design.Therefore the Empire State Building required careful design.
D) All snakes are reptiles.Therefore the Guatemalan milk snake is a reptile.
E) All organic compounds contain carbon.Therefore fructose contains carbon.
Accident Fallacy
Refers to a logical fallacy that involves applying a general rule to a specific case it does not apply to, often leading to erroneous conclusions.
- Comprehend the distinction between the fallacy of accident and how it is applied in real-life scenarios.
Verified Answer
NS
Nishan SinghJun 28, 2024
Final Answer :
B
Explanation :
The accident fallacy occurs when a general rule is applied to a specific case it was not intended to cover. In choice B, the general principle that it is wrong to take from others is improperly applied to the specific case of taxation by the government, which is a context where such a rule might not be intended to apply.
Learning Objectives
- Comprehend the distinction between the fallacy of accident and how it is applied in real-life scenarios.
Related questions
Assume That the Premise(s) of the Following Argument Are True ...
Assume That the Premise(s) of the Following Argument Are True ...
What Assumptions Humans Often Seem to Make Is the Basis ...
Consider This Argument: The Kidnappers Have Taken Eight People Hostage ...
What Assumption Humans Often Seem to Make Is the Basis ...