Asked by Amber Lloyd on Jul 29, 2024
Verified
Jill Homeowner contracts with Ralph Roofer for Ralph to reshingle Jill's roof.Midway through the job,Ralph says that he cannot finish unless Jill promises to pay him an additional $500.There is no real basis for this demand;Ralph just wants more money.Even though she could have gotten one of six other roofers to finish the job at a reasonable price,Jill gives in and promises to pay the $500,after which Ralph completes the job.Later,Jill refuses to pay the additional $500,and Ralph sues her.Jill defends on the basis of duress.What are the chances of this defense working?
Duress
Coercion or pressure unlawfully applied to force someone to act in a manner they otherwise would not.
Additional $500
An extra amount of five hundred dollars added to a transaction or financial agreement.
Real Basis
The fundamental or underlying reason or foundation for something.
- Understand the consequences of excessive persuasion and coercion in the realm of contract law.
- Distinguish among the myriad elements influencing the validity of a contract, including, but not limited to, concealment, duress, and undue influence.
Verified Answer
ZK
Zybrea KnightAug 03, 2024
Final Answer :
Jill is unlikely to have a defense here.Ralph's threat looks improper.However,it hardly seems very coercive,because Jill had a reasonable alternative.She could have gotten another roofer to finish the job.
Learning Objectives
- Understand the consequences of excessive persuasion and coercion in the realm of contract law.
- Distinguish among the myriad elements influencing the validity of a contract, including, but not limited to, concealment, duress, and undue influence.