Asked by Dylan Hunter on Jun 26, 2024

verifed

Verified

Is the Supreme Court an elite democratic or popular democratic institution? In what ways does it have features of or provide impetus for each theory?

Elite Democratic

A model of democracy that posits that a small number of individuals, often from privileged socio-economic backgrounds, exert significant influence over political decision-making and policies.

Popular Democratic

Referring to a political ideology or movement that blends elements of democracy with a strong appeal to the general populace, focusing on the needs and desires of the common people.

  • Pinpoint and understand the range of judicial perspectives and their repercussions on legal determinations.
  • Explain the significance and role of judicial review in the American legal system.
verifed

Verified Answer

AY
Ahmad YassineJul 02, 2024
Final Answer :
The Supreme Court can be seen as both an elite democratic and popular democratic institution, as it possesses features of and provides impetus for each theory.

On one hand, the Supreme Court can be viewed as an elite democratic institution because it is composed of nine justices who are appointed for life by the President and confirmed by the Senate. This means that the Court is insulated from direct popular control and is made up of individuals who are often seen as part of the political and legal elite. Additionally, the Court has the power to strike down laws passed by elected representatives, which some may argue is undemocratic as it allows a small group of unelected individuals to override the will of the majority.

On the other hand, the Supreme Court also has features of a popular democratic institution. The justices are ultimately accountable to the people through the nomination and confirmation process, and the Court has the power to protect the rights of minority groups and individuals from the potential tyranny of the majority. The Court's decisions can also reflect changing societal norms and values, and it has the ability to shape public opinion and influence the direction of public policy.

In conclusion, the Supreme Court can be seen as both an elite democratic and popular democratic institution, as it possesses features of and provides impetus for each theory. Its unique position as a check on the other branches of government and its ability to protect individual rights while also being insulated from direct popular control make it a complex and multifaceted institution within the American democratic system.