Asked by Merna Kayser on Jul 26, 2024

verifed

Verified

In the Chambly v.Bergevin case in 1994, three Jewish teachers were given an unpaid day off to celebrate Yom Kippur.The teachers' union raised a grievance, claiming that the loss of pay was discriminatory.How did the courts respond?

A) The courts disagreed, citing Yom Kippur as a non-traditional holiday.
B) The courts agreed that it was discriminatory because Christian co-workers received paid holidays for Christmas and Good Friday.
C) The courts disagreed, specifying that although Christmas and Good Friday are historically Christian-based, they had become statutory (non-religious) holidays.
D) The courts agreed that it was discriminatory because the three teachers had such devout beliefs.

Discriminatory

Showing bias or prejudice resulting in unfair treatment of individuals or groups based on characteristics such as race, age, or gender.

Yom Kippur

The holiest day of the Jewish year, also known as the Day of Atonement, during which individuals reflect upon their actions and seek forgiveness for their sins.

  • Understand the concept of religious accommodations and the criteria that qualify or disqualify them.
  • Recognize the role and rulings of human rights bodies in religious accommodation cases.
verifed

Verified Answer

LP
Layna PasiukJul 28, 2024
Final Answer :
B
Explanation :
The courts agreed that it was discriminatory because Christian co-workers received paid holidays for Christmas and Good Friday, highlighting an inconsistency in how religious holidays were treated in terms of paid leave.