Asked by Janicia Lockridge on Jul 06, 2024
Verified
Which of the following displays the informal fallacy of appeal to pity?
A) A man argues that you should believe that he is rich because,if you do not,he will punch you in the face.
B) A classmate concedes a disagreement with you,but only because she believes you are not smart enough to win a debate with her.
C) A student asks a teacher to give him an A in a course because,if he gets anything less,he will not get into medical school.
D) A woman argues that you must be wrong because you are a jerk.
Appeal to Pity
A logical fallacy that attempts to win an argument by exploiting the opponent's feelings of pity or guilt rather than by logic or reason.
Disagreement
A situation where two or more parties hold differing views, opinions, or positions on a particular issue or topic.
Debate
A formal discussion on a particular topic in a public meeting or legislative assembly, in which opposing arguments are put forward.
- Recognize and dissect the elements of numerous informal fallacies.
- Illuminate the varied nature between fallacies that are relevant, ambiguous, and assumption-driven.
Verified Answer
KM
Kylee McMainsJul 12, 2024
Final Answer :
C
Explanation :
The student is appealing to pity by suggesting that if they do not get an A, their future career goals will be jeopardized. This emotional appeal is not necessarily relevant to the merit of the student's performance in the course.
Learning Objectives
- Recognize and dissect the elements of numerous informal fallacies.
- Illuminate the varied nature between fallacies that are relevant, ambiguous, and assumption-driven.