Asked by Jason Mathew on May 05, 2024
Verified
Which of the following claims is true?
A) No one ever uses the traditional square of opposition anymore, since everyone agrees that it is based on a flawed view of existential import.
B) Some logicians still use the traditional square of opposition, but there is controversy over whether or not it is based on a flawed view of existential import.
C) Logicians now agree that the traditional square of opposition is based on the correct view of existential import, and they all now prefer it to the modern square.
D) Most logicians no longer use any square of opposition, but instead use the pentagon of opposition.
E) Most logicians no longer use any square of opposition, but instead use the hexagon of opposition.
Traditional Square
A diagrammatic representation of the logical relationships between categorical propositions in classical logic.
Existential Import
Pertains to the implication that some assertions within categorical logic assert the existence of at least one instance of something.
Opposition
Resistance or dissent, expressed in action or argument.
- Distinguish between contemporary and classical perspectives on existential import.
- Understand the relational dynamics among statements depicted in the square of opposition.
Verified Answer
ZK
Zybrea KnightMay 06, 2024
Final Answer :
B
Explanation :
While some logicians still use the traditional square of opposition, there is controversy over whether or not it is based on a flawed view of existential import. Therefore, claim B is the most accurate. The other claims are either completely false or overly specific.
Learning Objectives
- Distinguish between contemporary and classical perspectives on existential import.
- Understand the relational dynamics among statements depicted in the square of opposition.