logo
Ask Question

Asked by Bernardo Waincier on Jul 16, 2024

verifed

Verified

The question "Is it true that Doctor Watson was Holmes's best friend?" is paradoxical because

A) Watson frequently got in the way when Holmes was trying to solve a case.
B) there is no literal reality outside of our thoughts about it.
C) while it's true that Watson was Holmes's best friend in that fictional world, it's also true that Holmes had no best friend because he never existed.
D) Watson and Holmes never really knew each other.

Paradoxical

Involving a situation, statement, or condition that seems to contradict itself but may still be true.

Literal Reality

The aspect of reality that is understood and interpreted based on the explicit meaning of words and symbols, without inference.

Fictional World

An imaginary universe created in literature, movies, video games, or other media, characterized by its own set of rules, geography, and history.

  • Familiarize oneself with multiple philosophical approaches towards the appraisal and admiration of aesthetics and art.
verifed

Verified Answer

MT
Martin ThomasJul 22, 2024
Final Answer :
C
Explanation :
The question is paradoxical because it implies that there could be a contradiction between a fictional reality and actual reality. While it may be true that Watson was Holmes's best friend within the world of the Sherlock Holmes stories, it is also true that Holmes was a fictional character and therefore had no actual "best friend."

Related questions

David Hume Argues That an Artwork Is Valuable If It ...

What Did It Mean for Medieval Painters to Conceive of ...

Write a Fictional Argumentative Dialogue Between Two People Discussing the ...

Socrates, in Plato's Symposium, Argues That the Seeker of Beauty ...

Aristotle's Goal, in Analyzing the Art of the Theater, Was ...