Asked by brent ashley on May 28, 2024
Verified
The Michigan legislature is contemplating a new tax law that would affect Julie's business. Julie consults an attorney in order to sue the legislature. What should the attorney tell her?
A) That she does not have standing
B) That the case is moot
C) That the case is not ripe
D) That she would have to sue in federal court
E) That she does not have personal jurisdiction to bring the suit
Standing
The legal right to initiate a lawsuit, predicated on the party's stake in the outcome of the case.
Personal Jurisdiction
The power of a court to make decisions affecting the personal rights of a defendant.
Moot
refers to an issue or case that has been resolved or is no longer relevant, and therefore, there is no longer a need for court adjudication.
- Understand the basic principles of standing, mootness, ripeness, and personal jurisdiction in legal disputes.
Verified Answer
ZK
Zybrea KnightJun 04, 2024
Final Answer :
C
Explanation :
The attorney should tell Julie that the case is not ripe because the law has not yet been passed or taken effect, meaning there's no current harm to sue over.
Learning Objectives
- Understand the basic principles of standing, mootness, ripeness, and personal jurisdiction in legal disputes.
Related questions
Consumer Goods Corporation Sells Products That Are Poorly Made ...
The Legal Concepts of Case or Controversy and Ripeness Are ...
Should the Judge Have Disallowed Tamra's Testimony About What Aimee ...
Rosalba, a Resident of New Mexico, Claims That Pet Food ...
What Is a Court's Power to Hear a Case and ...