Asked by Carley Lambeth on Jul 24, 2024

verifed

Verified

Joe, a concert pianist, was walking down the street when he was struck by Harry, a careless skate boarder. Joe was knocked down and crushed his hand. When Joe sued Harry for his negligence, claiming the loss of income from his profession (he could never play the piano again), Harry countered with the defence that there was no way he could have anticipated that the person he was going to hit was a concert pianist. Explain his likelihood of success in raising this defence.

Concert Pianist

A professional pianist who performs solo recitals, concertos with orchestras, and chamber music in concert halls.

Negligence

The failure to exercise the care that a reasonably prudent person would exercise in similar circumstances, resulting in harm or damage.

Loss of Income

A monetary loss resulting from an inability to work and earn money due to injury, disability, or other reasons.

  • Understand the concept of negligence and its applicability in different scenarios.
verifed

Verified Answer

SM
sushmi maharjanJul 27, 2024
Final Answer :
You take your victim the way you find him, and the fact that the damages are unusual because of the special circumstances of the victim is no defence.