Asked by Angelina Tornetto on May 12, 2024
Verified
Is the following syllogism valid? No Internet service provider is a small business.
Some businesses in our town are small businesses.
Some businesses in our town are not Internet service providers.
A) Yes, regardless of whether we take the traditional or modern view of existential import.
B) No, regardless of whether we take the traditional or modern view of existential import.
C) Yes if we take the modern view of existential import, but no if we take the traditional view.
D) Yes if we take the traditional view of existential import, but no if we take the modern view.
E) There is not enough information to determine the answer.
Internet Service Provider
A company that provides customers with access to the Internet.
Small Business
An independently owned and operated company that is limited in size and revenue depending on the industry.
Existential Import
The implication that a statement or proposition presupposes the existence of certain entities it refers to, affecting its truth value.
- Implement the criteria of validity to examine the soundness of categorical syllogisms.
- Examine the relationship between existential import and the validation of syllogistic arguments.
Verified Answer
SP
Subramanya PutalekarMay 12, 2024
Final Answer :
A
Explanation :
The syllogism is valid in both traditional and modern views of existential import because it logically follows that if no Internet service provider is a small business, and some businesses in our town are small businesses, then some businesses in our town are not Internet service providers.
Learning Objectives
- Implement the criteria of validity to examine the soundness of categorical syllogisms.
- Examine the relationship between existential import and the validation of syllogistic arguments.