Asked by Jamie PARKER on May 19, 2024

verifed

Verified

Hardware retailers Deuce Hardware Co.and Trueblue Hardware Corp.agreed to a schedule of maximum prices that they will pay to hardware wholesalers with whom they deal.What is the most likely stance that the Supreme Court will take under these circumstances?

A) Their action will be deemed unlawful according to the rule of reason analysis.
B) Their action will be deemed lawful because only sellers can be guilty of price-fixing.
C) Their action will be deemed lawful if their agreement results in savings to consumers.
D) Their action will be deemed unlawful according to the per se analysis.

Per Se Analysis

Per se analysis is a legal doctrine under antitrust laws where certain activities or agreements are considered illegal without the need for further inquiry into their actual harm or purpose, due to their inherently anti-competitive nature.

Rule Of Reason

A legal doctrine used to interpret antitrust laws, focusing on the reasonableness of business practices and their effects on competition.

Price-Fixing

An agreement among competitors to raise, fix, or otherwise maintain the price at which their goods or services are sold, which is illegal under antitrust law.

  • Analyze the legality of various business practices under antitrust laws, such as price-fixing, exclusive dealing, and tying agreements.
verifed

Verified Answer

KG
Karan GiareMay 25, 2024
Final Answer :
D
Explanation :
Through their agreement,Deuce and Trueblue are trying to interfere with market forces and control prices (a case of horizontal price-fixing).The Supreme Court continues to adhere to the long-standing rule of per se illegality for any form of horizontal price-fixing.